My Favorite Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream

|

Let’s talk about one of my new favorite kitchen gadgets: the Ninja Creami. And my favorite protein ice cream!

If you haven’t discovered this magic machine yet, you need to know that it is the appliance that has completely changed the way I make frozen desserts and drinks at home. Whether you’re into healthy treats, indulgent ice creams, or refreshing summer drinks, the Ninja Creami does it all with ease.

Overhead view of a food processor filled with blended ice cream next to a glass containing chunks of chocolate chip cookie dough on a white surface.
A bright, airy kitchen with white cabinets, wooden dining table, and wicker chairs. Sunlight streams in through large windows, highlighting yellow flowers on the table and counter.
What's Cooking?

Protein Ice Cream in the Ninja Creami

Six clear glasses each containing a scoop of chocolate ice cream are arranged in two rows of three on a white surface.

Why the Ninja Creami is the Best Way to Make Frozen Desserts and Drinks

Chocolate ice cream mixture in a food processor, viewed from above, with smooth and creamy texture visible inside the bowl.

I recently used the Ninja Creami to make protein ice cream, and I couldn’t believe how creamy, flavorful, and satisfying it turned out to be. It tasted like a decadent dessert, but it was packed with protein and didn’t leave any of my guests feeling guilty.

Once I discovered how easy it was, I started experimenting with mix-ins like Oreo cookies, edible cookie dough, and chopped Reese’s peanut butter cups. Let’s say… the possibilities are endless.

What is the Ninja Creami?

A Ninja coffee maker with a glass carafe sits on a kitchen countertop next to white ceramic containers.

The Ninja Creami is a countertop appliance that turns almost any liquid into a scoopable frozen treat. Unlike traditional ice cream makers that churn for hours and require pre-freezing a bowl, the Creami works differently.

You freeze your mixture overnight in a Ninja Creami pint container, then place it into the machine and let the Creami spin it into ice cream, sorbet, gelato, milkshakes, or even frozen drinks. It’s fast, user-friendly, and wildly customizable.

Why I Love It

A Ninja ice cream maker is processing ingredients with the "Frozen Yogurt" setting selected. The machine's container is frosted and locked in place.
  • Customizable Ingredients: You control everything that goes in, from sugar and fat content to mix-ins and flavors.
  • Easy to Use: The process is simple: mix, freeze, spin, enjoy.
  • Endless Variety: Ice cream, sorbet, smoothie bowls, slushies, milkshakes, and even frozen cocktails.
  • Great for Healthy Eating: You can make high-protein, low-carb, or dairy-free versions of your favorite frozen treats.
  • Fun to Experiment With: From classic flavors to wild creations, you can try it all.

How to Make Protein Ice Cream with the Ninja Creami

A variety of protein products, including Muscle Milk powder, Fairlife Core Power shakes, Fairlife chocolate milk, and two boxes of Jell-O, displayed on a kitchen counter.

After reading rave reviews and seeing countless videos online, I decided to try making my protein ice cream using a few simple ingredients. I wanted something that felt indulgent but was also packed with protein and easy to whip up with pantry staples.

Here’s the recipe that worked beautifully for me, and I’ll share how I turned it into three different delicious flavors using fun mix-ins.

🥄 Basic Protein Ice Cream Base (Chocolate or Vanilla)

A clear plastic cup containing a portion of milk sits on a white, marbled surface.

Ingredients:

  • 1 Fairlife Core Power Protein Shake or Fairlife Vanilla Protein Shake (either Chocolate or Vanilla, 11.5 oz)*
  • 1 tbsp instant pudding mix (sugar-free chocolate or vanilla to match)

*You can also use milk (such as Fairlife), but add one scoop of protein powder

Instructions:

A blender filled with a light brown liquid mixture, some ingredients settled at the bottom, sits on a kitchen countertop.
Four clear containers with colorful lids are filled with different liquids or mixtures, placed on a white kitchen counter.
Four plastic containers with colored lids (green, pink, gray, beige) are stored in a refrigerator drawer.
A Ninja ice cream maker in operation, blending a frozen mixture inside a clear container with visible ice crystals.
  1. Pour the protein shake and pudding into a blender. Mix.
  2. Pour the combined mixture into a Ninja Creami pint container.
  3. Seal the lid and freeze flat for at least 24 hours.
  4. When ready, remove the lid and insert the pint into the Ninja Creami.
  5. Run the “Ice Cream” function. If it looks crumbly, use the “Re-Spin” feature until smooth and creamy.

I may occasionally use affiliate links on this blog, which means I earn a small commission if you purchase through the link. The price will be the same whether you use the affiliate link or go directly to the vendor’s website using a non-affiliate link

Ninja kitchen appliance with a clear blending container filled with a white mixture, next to three ingredient jars topped with gray, yellow, and red lids—perfect for blending powders. Great deal available on Amazon Prime Day.

Ninja CREAMi Deluxe Ice Cream & Frozen Treat Maker

Ninja ice cream maker with a digital control panel, transparent mixing container, and rotating lid, shown on a white background.
Ninja Swirl by CREAMi Ice Cream and Soft Serve Maker,
Ninja Creami appliance making a frozen dessert, with control panel options visible and a container of partially blended mixture inside the machine.
Ninja Creami
Eight bottles of Fairlife Core Power Vanilla flavored protein shakes, each bottle labeled with “26g Complete Protein.”.
Fairlife, Core Power, 26 Gram Protein Shakes, Vanilla 8 Pack
Two resealable bags of Equip Prime Protein powder, one vanilla flavor and one chocolate flavor, labeled as grass-fed beef isolate powder and marked free from gluten, dairy, and soy.
Equip Foods Chocolate Prime Protein Powder – Vanilla & Chocolate 
Eight bottles of fairlife Nutrition Plan Chocolate protein shake, each labeled with 30g protein and images of chocolate pieces on the packaging.
VersioFairIife Nutrition-Plan Protein Shakes – 30g Protein Shake, Milk Chocolaten 1.0.0

🍪 Flavor Ideas Using Mix-Ins

An open bag of Reese's Minis unwrapped chocolates next to a food processor containing chocolate mixture on a white surface.

Once you have your creamy base, the real fun begins! Use the “Mix-In” setting to add your favorite treats after the initial spin.

1. Vanilla Cookies & Cream

A food processor filled with blended, creamy white ice cream, shown from above on a white surface.
Let’s talk about one of my new favorite kitchen gadgets: the Ninja Creami. And my favorite protein ice cream.
  • Base: Vanilla protein ice cream
  • Mix-In: 2 crushed Oreo cookies

2. Edible Cookie Dough Delight

A food processor bowl containing a creamy, pale mixture with visible chunks, likely blended with add-ins such as nuts or chocolate chips.
  • Base: Vanilla protein ice cream
  • Mix-In: 1–2 tbsp chopped edible cookie dough (store-bought or homemade)

3. Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup

An open bag of Reese's Minis unwrapped chocolates next to a food processor containing chocolate mixture on a white surface.
  • Base: Chocolate protein ice cream
  • Mix-In: 2 chopped mini Reese’s peanut butter cups

Optional Enhancements:

  • Add 1 tbsp cocoa powder to intensify the chocolate flavor
  • Add a splash of vanilla extract for a flavor boost
  • Swirl in a spoonful of peanut butter or caramel before freezing for extra richness

Tips for Success

A top-down view of a food processor containing thick, whipped chocolate mixture with a hollow center.
  • Freeze Completely Flat: The Creami needs a flat, even surface to work correctly.
  • Use the Re-Spin Button: Don’t panic if it looks powdery after the first spin. Re-spin until creamy! Please note that I had to do this every time.
  • Try Other Base Variations: Greek yogurt and milk, almond milk and banana, or even coffee and creamer combos.
  • Label Your Pints: If you start making lots of flavors (you will!), labeling the lids helps keep track.
A light blue portable label printer with a circular black screen, a printed label coming out, and a roll of label paper placed beside it.
Label Maker Machine
Four white storage containers with pastel-colored lids (brown, yellow, green, and peach) are shown, along with a silver ice cream scoop in the background.
Nuenen 5 Pack Ice Cream Containers 1Qt Freezer Storage Tubs 
Four textured plastic containers with colored lids (green, blue, yellow, pink) and measurement markings, each filled with a light-colored, speckled substance.
Premium 24 oz. Pint Containers for Ninja Creami Deluxe

More Ideas for the Ninja Creami

Two clear plastic cups and two bottles of Casamigos Cocktail Mixer are placed on a kitchen counter with a refrigerator and cabinets in the background.
Two clear plastic containers with lids, partially filled with orange liquid, sit on a white kitchen counter; kitchen cabinets and appliances are visible in the background.
A close-up of a countertop ice cream maker containing partially churned ice cream, with ingredients and containers visible in the background.
Two clear glasses with frothy beverages sit on a wooden surface; the left glass contains a yellow liquid, while the right glass contains a beige liquid.

We made Frozen Paloma cocktails with Casa Amigos Paloma mix. I froze it in the tub, then used the SLUSHi setting and made cocktails with tequila! We were able to serve just the frozen slushi for our non-drinking guests.

  • Frozen Lemonade: Blend lemon juice, water, and a touch of honey for a frosty treat
  • Mocktails or Slushies: Freeze fruit juices with fresh herbs like mint or basil
  • Boozy Creamis: Make a frozen piña colada, peach bellini, or margarita with a grown-up twist
  • Smoothie Bowls: Freeze your smoothie blend and serve it thick like soft-serve for a breakfast treat
Four ribbed glasses with gold rims contain colorful drinks garnished with lime, cherries, mint, orange peel, and ice. Two empty glasses are visible in the background.
Ripple Unbreakable Stemless Plastic Cups
Four margarita glasses filled with green and pink frozen drinks, garnished with lime slices and strawberries, on a white background.
HOST FREEZE Margarita Cocktail Glasses
Five small wooden bowls containing different foods, including olives, cheese cubes, a creamy dip with seeds, and a light orange sauce, with two empty wooden bowls stacked nearby.
Set of 6 Acacia wood small bowls

Final Thoughts

The Ninja Creami is more than a novelty appliance. It’s truly a game-changer for anyone who loves frozen desserts. Whether you’re trying to meet your protein goals, beat the heat, or get creative in the kitchen, this machine makes it easy and enjoyable.

If you’ve been thinking about buying one or already have one sitting in the box, take this as your sign to go for it. Start with this protein ice cream recipe and play around with flavors you love. I guarantee once you make your first pint, you’ll be hooked.

Happy spinning, scooping, and snacking!

Four clear plastic containers with pastel-colored lids in green, blue, pink, and gray, each marked with a "MAX FILL" line near the top.
Containers Replacement for Ninja Creami
A blue-handled professional ice cream scoop with a metal scooping end and a tag showing color options and branding.
Ice Cream Scoop with Soft Grip Handle
Two white one-quart containers with blue lids are shown, alongside a tag indicating size and available lid colors.
1 Qt Premium Ice Cream Containers, Set of 2
A white ice cream scoop with a metal head is shown next to three scoops of ice cream topped with syrup, berries, and strawberries—perfect for enjoying during summer at the beach.

Heated Ice Cream Scoop

Six ribbed glass dessert bowls are arranged in two rows, with one bowl containing scoops of pink and yellow ice cream garnished with mint and wafers.
Set of 6 Glass Ice Cream Bowls
Four white ceramic bowls with different raised geometric patterns are stacked together, with the top bowl slightly tilted to the side.
LE TAUCI Small Bowls 8 oz
Order my book, A HOME to SHARE, here!

If you enjoy my blog, you can sign up to receive my updates here.

.

Neutral Kitchen Decor Favorites

A collage of neutral-toned kitchen decor items, including utensils, bowls, a mixer, knives, trays, dishes, salt and pepper shakers, and kitchen towels, arranged on a white background.
SHOP HERE
Shop My Home
Favorite Finds This Month on Amazon

Latest Posts

My Recent Instagram Posts

You can pin the image below to your boards on Pinterest (click the Pin button in the top left corner) or follow me on Pinterest!

A food processor bowl filled with creamy ice cream sits next to a small glass of cookie dough pieces. Text reads, "My Favorite Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream.

For more real-time updates, follow me on Instagram @My100YearOldHome

Similar Posts

One Comment

  1. This is such a fun and practical guide! I love how customizable the Ninja Creami is—especially the protein ice cream variations. Definitely inspired to try the Oreo mix-in first!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *